The Best Seafood Delivery Services of

How We Chose The Best Seafood Delivery Services

If you love seafood but don’t love the quality or variety found at your local grocery store, a seafood delivery service is an excellent solution. These services send premium quality seafood of your choosing directly to your door, making it easy to enjoy the best of the ocean without ever leaving the comfort of your home.

But not all seafood delivery services are created equal. Here’s a look at the criteria we used when compiling our list of the top brands on the market today:

Large Selection of Seafood

The best seafood delivery services offer an expansive selection of fresh, frozen and/or live fish, shellfish and more. Their product lines include common catches like salmon, shrimp, crab and lobster, and more exotic options like squid and octopus for the adventurous crowd. Many services offer both wild caught and farm raised options at varying price points, and a variety of combo boxes that bundle together a few different products. Some even give you the option to build your own box so you get exactly what you want. Several of our top picks also sell seasonings, soups and other grocery items that you can add to your order at any time.

Focus on Quality 

There are a number of ways to determine the quality of a catch, including how it looks, how it smells, how it feels, how long it’s been out of the water, etc. The best seafood delivery services prioritize quality control—they have seafood experts hand-selecting each catch prior to boxing it up and shipping it to your home to ensure you only receive the highest quality products. They also use special packaging designed to preserve the freshness of the seafood when it’s in transport.

Transparent About Sourcing 

The top seafood delivery services source their catches from reputable fisheries and suppliers. They may work with local and/or international partners depending on the species they’re procuring, but either way, they are completely transparent about where their products come from. They empower you, the consumer to make important decisions about your food—like if you’d prefer wild caught or farm raised seafood, for example, by providing origin information about every catch.

Generous Portion Sizes

If you’re going to pay to have top tier seafood delivered directly to your door, you want to be sure you’ll feel satisfied once you eat it. The seafood delivery services on our list all send generously sized portions of every product they sell. Many have established size or weight standards, which help them maintain portion consistency so you always get exactly what you pay for.

Reasonable Pricing

Of course, cost is a consideration when choosing the top seafood delivery services. The best options are reasonably priced, and their price tags accurately reflect the quality of their products. They don’t charge an arm and a leg for shipping, and many offer discounts if you commit to an ongoing subscription versus a one-time purchase. The companies included on our list all frequently hold promotions that reduce their prices even further.

Flexible Delivery

With most of the seafood delivery services on our list, you can opt for a one-time shipment, or you can sign up for a subscription service and enjoy having recurring shipments sent to your home. Many of these companies also offer you a choice of delivery days and/or delivery times. And, if you need to pause, skip or delay a shipment, the best meal delivery services allow for that, too—penalty-free.

Commitment to Sustainability

The best seafood delivery services make an effort to minimize their impact on the environment and marine life. Most employ sustainable fishing practices and are certified by the Marine Stewardship Council (MSC), which focuses on wild caught seafood, ensuring that fisheries are managed sustainably, and/or the Aquaculture Stewardship Council (ASC), which focuses on farmed seafood, ensuring that aquaculture practices are environmentally and socially responsible. The best services also minimize bycatch mortality (the death of other marine animals that are caught in fishing gear unintentionally), and use eco-friendly shipping materials and food packaging that can be recycled or reused.

Cooking Tips & Recipes

Seafood delivery services make it possible for you to sample a variety of seafood, including options you might never have tried before. But since that means you may be venturing into uncharted territory, the best companies offer preparation/cooking tips and even chef crafted recipes to help you get the most out of your seafood.

Positive Customer Reviews

If you’re hesitant to purchase seafood sight unseen, positive customer reviews can provide the peace of mind you need to take the plunge. If actual customers are raving about the quality, flavor and freshness of a seafood delivery service’s products, you can probably assume you’re good to go. The best companies are also praised for their customer service and satisfaction guarantees, and have been rated highly by credible organizations like the Better Business Bureau (BBB).

Satisfaction Guarantees

The top services have generous guarantees that demonstrate their commitment to your satisfaction. Most of the companies on our list will replace your seafood or refund you if there are issues with your seafood or your shipments.