Fulton Fish Market Meal Delivery Review

Fulton Fish: How it Works

Getting started with FultonFishMarket.com is a simple process that begins with deciding whether you’d like to sign up for a subscription or place a one-time order. Subscription members can choose their shipping frequency, and earn exclusive perks like product discounts, complimentary gifts and priority customer service, so it’s definitely worth considering.

From there, you’ll select your seafood, using the website’s helpful filters to sort by type, preparation requirements, price and more. If you opted for a subscription, you’ll then indicate your preferred delivery frequency. Next, you’ll enter your payment information and place your order. 

Your order will arrive within the timeframe indicated, in special packaging designed to preserve freshness and quality (see our Shipping & Delivery section for more details on that). If you signed up for a subscription plan, you’ll receive an email three days prior to your next shipment so you can change, pause or skip your next order.

Fulton Fish Market Products

Fulton Fish Market stands out for its massive selection of freshly frozen, live and prepared seafood products. Here’s a taste of some of the options you’ll find on the Fulton Fish Market menu:

Fulton Fish Market also offers a wide variety of pantry staples like canned seafood, sauces and spices, plus kitchen tools, tableware and books. The company also offers prepared, ready-to-eat options like bacon wrapped seafood, bagels, burgers, cakes, crab legs, lobster meat and smoked seafood, plus curated bundles and combo boxes.

Shipping & Delivery

When you place your order, you’ll be able to select a delivery date that works for you. What you’ll pay for shipping depends on what you order. Freshly frozen items ship for free when you order more than $125 worth. Orders containing less than $125 of these items will ship at a flat rate of $19.99 nationwide. Free shipping is also available on additional, eligible products.

If your order includes a mix of live/fresh and shelf stable items, they will ship in separate boxes to ensure optimal freshness. If your order includes frozen items, they will ship with dry ice and arrive frozen. They are in transit for one to two days and will be delivered on the date you select. Live and fresh items ship with gel packs and will be cool but not frozen upon arrival. They are in transit for one day and delivered on the date you select at checkout. Shelf-stable products are typically delivered within three to five days of your order placement.

Fulton Fish Market Pricing

Fulton Fish’s sprawling selection includes options for seafood lovers of every taste and budget. The price you’ll pay for your order depends heavily on the products you select. If you’re craving salmon, for example, there are nearly 10 different product options to choose from, including very affordable single servings and pricier multi-portion bundles. You can opt for a five- to seven-ounce center cut portion of Atlantic Salmon, which retails for just $12.99, or you can spring for a 2.5- to three-pound King Salmon Fillet, which will cost you $118. If you want to know more about the pricing, you can simply visit the company’s website—all product prices are listed and easy to compare.

About Fulton Fish Market

The Fulton Fish Market is one of the oldest and largest seafood markets in the world. It is comprised of more than 20 reputable seafood companies that are primarily focused on sourcing top restaurants and wholesalers across the country. FultonFishMarket.com makes it possible for seafood lovers nationwide to access all that the market has to offer—from fish to shellfish to pantry items and prepared meals. The company works in partnership with the market’s fishmongers to select the very best catches and conveniently ship them to customers’ homes. Fulton Fish Market’s expansive selection, transparency about its seafood’s origins and nutrition, and commitment to responsible sourcing make it a one stop shop for customers of every palate, preference and budget.

Customer Service

Fulton Fish Market receives high praise for their customer service, which customers say is easily accessible and extremely helpful. The customer service team is available Monday through Friday from 7 a.m. to 8 p.m. EST, and Saturdays 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. EST. They can be reached by phone (718-842-8908), text (909-639-4087) email ([email protected] ), or chat. The company’s website is also home to a helpful FAQ section, which addresses commonly asked questions by potential and existing customers. 

Sustainability Information

Fulton Fish Market offers a wide variety of responsibly sourced seafood, procured from wild fisheries and sustainable aquaculture producers.

The company prides itself on its meticulous selection and stringent vetting process, which includes screening each catch according to the impact on the species, the surrounding environment, the fishing communities and more.

Fulton Fish Market is also very transparent about the origins of their seafood, enabling you to make an informed decision about the products you select.

Fulton Fish Market vs. Other Top Brands

Fulton Fish Market is one of the most iconic names in premium seafood delivery, known for its massive selection and restaurant-quality sourcing, but there are a few other options on the market. Here’s a look at how the company compares to Wild Alaskan Company, Sea to Table, and ButcherBox:

Wild Alaskan vs. Fulton Fish Market

Wild Alaskan Company and Fulton Fish Market both deliver high-quality seafood to your door, but their models are entirely different. While Wild Alaskan operates as a highly curated, subscription-only service focused strictly on wild-caught fish from the Pacific Northwest and Alaska, Fulton Fish Market functions as a massive, a-la-carte online marketplace.

As a result, Fulton offers a vastly wider selection. You’ll find hundreds of options including live shellfish, luxury caviar, specialty items, and both responsibly farmed and wild-caught freshly frozen fish. While Wild Alaskan focuses heavily on their specific regional catches, Fulton Fish Market actually offers premium Wild Alaskan products as well—including highly sought-after, world-class catches from the famous Copper River—albeit at a slightly higher price point.

If you want a highly convenient, set-it-and-forget-it subscription of everyday wild-caught Alaskan salmon, Wild Alaskan is an excellent choice. However, if you are looking for specific cuts, premium Copper River salmon, massive variety, or the flexibility to shop without a recurring subscription, Fulton Fish Market provides a much more expansive experience.

Sea to Table vs. Fulton Fish Market

Sea to Table and Fulton Fish Market both deliver premium seafood directly to consumers, but their sourcing philosophies and catalogs differ significantly. Sea to Table strictly limits its offerings to 100% United States wild-caught seafood that is exclusively shipped frozen.

In contrast, Fulton Fish Market sources globally, providing access not only to domestic favorites but also to international delicacies like New Zealand King Salmon or Chilean Sea Bass. While both companies ensure their fish is freshly frozen to lock in peak quality, Fulton also offers a wide array of live shellfish and specialty items, all shipped overnight on dry ice.

Because Fulton Fish Market offers highly premium, restaurant-grade items alongside everyday filets, its price ceiling is noticeably higher, though standard cuts remain very competitive. Eco-conscious consumers who prefer to strictly support domestic fisheries may lean toward Sea to Table, while those looking for live shellfish, specialty raw bar items, or a wider global selection of premium fish will find Fulton Fish Market to be the better fit.

ButcherBox vs. Fulton Fish Market

While ButcherBox is primarily known as a premium meat delivery service specializing in grass-fed beef and free-range chicken, they do offer a small selection of seafood. ButcherBox provides reliable staples like frozen wild-caught salmon, cod, and scallops, which are usually purchased as an add-on to a recurring monthly meat subscription.

Fulton Fish Market, on the other hand, is a historic institution entirely dedicated to chef-quality seafood. They offer hundreds of specialized items ranging from everyday freshly frozen filets to live, luxury raw bar centerpieces—all without locking customers into a mandatory subscription.

ButcherBox is a solid, convenient choice for a busy household that primarily eats meat but wants to mix in a few standard fish portions each month. However, for true seafood lovers, pescatarians, or anyone planning to host a premium dinner, the limited seafood menu at ButcherBox cannot compete with the depth and quality of Fulton Fish Market’s catalog.

Bottom Line: Why We Love It

Fulton Fish Market brings the best of the ocean to seafood lovers’ homes nationwide. The company offers a massive selection of premium quality seafood sourced from one of the oldest and largest seafood markets in the entire world, plus convenient home delivery. We love that it customers can customize their order, choosing from hundreds of frozen, live/fresh and shelf stable seafood products plus curated boxes, bundles and prepared options. We also appreciate that the company offers both subscription and a la carte ordering options, as well as options for every budget. The company has amassed an impressive collection of positive reviews from real customers who praise the quality of the seafood, the reasonable pricing, the commitment to sustainability, and the fast and convenient shipping.