OUR REVIEW PROCESS
Committed to transparent, unbiased reviews to help you shop confidently and make informed decisions.
Our team of experts is composed of professional writers and editors who follow an extensive, multi-step review process. Our reviewers monitor search trends and consumer demand, perform research and market analysis, collect verified customer feedback, and have industry experts weigh in on final selection.
Criteria
We evaluate mattresses using a consistent set of criteria that reflect real-world sleep needs. This includes comfort and firmness accuracy, support, temperature regulation, material quality, durability, overall value, and brand reputation.
Research
Our research includes product specification and materials review, pricing and value, warranty and trial terms, real-world performance, and customer feedback to identify which mattresses we recommend.
Testing
When possible, mattresses are evaluated through hands-on or structured performance testing. When hands-on testing isn't available, we evaluate the mattress based on the available information regarding materials, construction, and design features.
Evaluation
Each mattress’s performance across comfort, support, cooling, and value is evaluated alongside brand policies such as trial periods, warranties, and return terms. We also compare each mattress to similar products within its price range and construction category. This helps ensure the final rating reflects both product quality and overall competitiveness in the market.
Rating System
Each mattress is assigned a score based on how well it performs across the key evaluation areas. These assessments contribute to an overall rating on a 1–10 scale, reflecting the mattress’s performance relative to other options in the category. For easier comparison, the score is also displayed as a 1–5 star rating, giving readers a quick visual summary of overall performance.
Our Commitment to Transparency
Consumer Rating is committed to transparent, trustworthy editorial standards. This is why we ensure every article we publish adheres to strict ethical guidelines:
Unbiased Reviews
Our writers do not receive payments or incentives that could influence their reviews.
Independent Testing
We ensure all evaluations are based on verifiable, unbiased testing methods.
Regular Updates
Our reviews are regularly updated to reflect new data and improvements.
User Contributions
We encourage real users to share their experiences and insights.
We may earn a small commission if you purchase through an affiliate link on our site. It’s how we keep Consumer Rating completely free for you!
Our Rating System
Our ratings reflect the criteria consumers care about most—like pricing, product benefits, features and performance. Here are the key factors considered in our ratings:
-Features & Benefits
– Real World Performance
– Quality & Reliability
– Ease of Use
– Price & Value
Why This Process Matters
Making a purchase should make your life easier, better and more enjoyable—not more complicated. This is why we do the research for you, to help you cut through the noise, save time and make informed purchasing decisions you can feel good about.
Best Mattresses
Whether you’re a side sleeper, a back sleeper, a stomach sleeper, or some combination of the three, there’s a mattress for you. We pull back the covers on the best mattresses for every kind of sleeper and body type, so you can rest easy knowing you’re picking the best mattress for you.
Best Overall Mattress
Limited Time Offer!
Save $300 Off $1K+ Orders
- Firmness: Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, Firm
- Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King, Split King, Split Cal King
- Materials: Euro pillow top, memory foam & dual carbon steel coil construction
- Design: Hybrid innerspring design with patented spinal zone technology for optimal alignment & back/joint pain relief
- Trial Period: 365-night home trial
- Warranty: Lifetime warranty
- Shipping: Free white glove delivery & setup, free mattress removal
- Official Mattress of Team USA and the LA28 Olympic & Paralympic Games
Limited Time Offer!
Save $300 Off $1K+ Orders
Mattress Reviews
Dreaming of a new mattress but feeling a little overwhelmed by all the types, features and brands? Don’t lose sleep over it! Our trusted experts have put in countless hours researching the best mattresses and personally testing each and every one—so you don’t have to.
Mattress Buying Guide
Looking for something specific? We laid out the top mattresses in the top categories to make it easier. There’s something for every type of mattress and every type of sleeper, and they’re the deep dive you’ve been looking for in your pursuit of the best night of sleep ever.
Methodology
The Consumer Rating Difference
In-Depth Reviews of the Top Rated Mattresses
Need a new mattress but not sure where to begin? Our experts dive deep into the details—so you don’t have to.
Within each mattress review, you’ll find:
Comprehensive Overviews
From materials and construction, to motion isolation and temperature control, plus warranties and sleep trials—we cover everything that matters about mattresses.
Pricing Details
We break down how much each mattress costs by model type and size, noting everything that’s included with a purchase, plus sales and promotions to look for.
Mattress Comparisons
From innersprings to memory foam, hybrids to latex, we compare each mattress to similar models, so you can see how they stack up against the competition.