Paychex

As a business owner, you’re responsible for paying your employees on time and staying compliant with payroll taxes and other employment regulations. The more staff you have, the more time consuming and complicated this becomes. This is where a payroll service can be beneficial, freeing up your time to work on other areas of your business and ensuring peace of mind that things are done correctly, and on time.

In this review, we’ll explore Paychex, a leading name in the payroll industry, and take a deep dive into their offerings, which go far beyond payroll processing to include a full suite of support for businesses of all sizes.

Last Updated 

Paychex Hero
brand logo

9.5

9.5

Get Your Estimate Now

Highlights
Easy-to-use online payroll and HR
Automated tax administration
Flexible plans for businesses of all sizes
World-class compliance expertise

About Paychex

Paychex was founded in 1971, and over the past 50-plus years in business, has become a leading provider of payroll, HR and employee benefits solutions. The company’s goal is to help businesses succeed by making complex challenges “brilliantly simple,” and they do so with a unique combination of digital HR technology and advisory services, and a comprehensive, cloud-based solution that integrates HR, employee benefits, insurance services and payroll into a single, easy-to-use platform. Businesses can select the services they need now, and easily add on new products as they grow.

Pros Cons
24/7 chat and phone support Some features only available as an add-on and not included with any plan
Easily enter and run payroll in as few as two clicks Must speak with a representative for pricing information
Scalable payroll solutions and flexible plans to grow with you
Customizable add-on services—don’t pay for what you don’t need
Automatic payroll tax calculations and payment
Compliance information to help you stay ahead of changes
Flexible fast payment options including same-day ACH
Recruiting, hiring and onboarding services
Robust analytics and custom reports to help you make informed decisions
Range of time and attendance tools, including physical and biometric time clocks
Comprehensive employee insurance and benefits packages
Employee self-service portal for payroll, benefits and personal information
Business insurance coverage for your business, property and employees
Access to certified HR experts and HR resource center
Easy-to-use app to run payroll and complete simple tasks on the go

Services & Features

Paychex has the ability to support businesses of all sizes, whether you have two employees or 2,000, with a full suite of smart solutions that benefit everyone, regardless of business size. Next, we’ll give an overview of Paychex’s services, including payroll, employee benefits, HR services and more, to help you determine whether it’s the right option for you.

Payroll Services

Paychex allows businesses to easily manage employees and control payroll costs with their all-in-one Paychex Flex technology. 

Here’s what business owners can expect when using Paychex for payroll:

  • Easily run payroll from desktop or mobile app with the option to work with a dedicated payroll specialist
  • Integrate payroll with HR and benefits for more seamless management 
  • Automatic tax administration service calculates, pays and files payroll taxes and generates year-end W2s and 1099s
  • Give employees the freedom to choose from flexible payment options, including paper checks, direct deposit and pay cards
  • Garnishment payment service automatically deducts and remits garnished wages to the appropriate agency
  • General ledger service easily transfers payroll data to your accounting software to help improve efficiency, workflow and accuracy 
  • Optional add-on service for fast payroll payment options, including real-time payments and same-day ACH
  • Paychex Pre-check allows admins and employees to preview paystubs, identifying discrepancies and possible errors before payroll processes
  • Add-on expense management services make it easy for employees to submit expenses and managers to approve them for reimbursements
  • Employee self-service allows employees to view pay and tax information, enroll in benefits and update personal information 

Employee Benefits

In a competitive labor market, offering comprehensive employee benefits is often a necessity. To give you an edge, Paychex offers a wide variety of add-on services, allowing you to create a benefits solution that fits your specific business needs—and not pay for features you don’t use. 

Here’s an overview of what you can do with Paychex’s benefits services:

  • Attract and retain the best talent with access to cost-effective, comprehensive benefits packages that are adaptable your business needs
  • Paychex is the number one provider of 401(k) plans in the U.S.—add on this service to get help with everything from choosing plans to enrollment and plan maintenance
  • Add on options for FSA, HSA and HRAs, COBRA and premium-only plans
  • Customize your plan with the add-on services you need, including full-service benefits administration and employee self-service
  • Make your employee benefits easier to manage with more efficient record keeping

Time & Attendance

Paychex Flex Time is a cloud-based time and attendance system that fully integrates with the Paychex Flex payroll platform for automated payroll processing. This service helps you save time, prevent errors and connect employees with the information they need. 

Here are some of the benefits of using this service:

  • Seamless integration with Paychex payroll processing 
  • Flexible, accurate time tracking via web punch, mobile app, kiosk app with facial verification, biometric iris and fingerscan time clocks, and more
  • Geofencing and geolocation capabilities for time tracking
  • Scheduling tool with templates, shift swapping and schedule exceptions 
  • Overtime rules with notifications for employees approaching overtime
  • Calendar integration, email alerts and employee messaging capabilities 
  • Location-based mileage calculator for simple, accurate, payroll-integrated mileage reimbursements
  • Automated time-off requests, accruals and PTO tracking—reduce manual calculations and give employees a real-time view of PTO balances
  • Detailed reporting on job costing, labor distribution, forecasting and more allows you to make strategic business decisions

HR Services

Paychex offers a wide range of HR services, too. For businesses with minimal HR needs, there are one-off talent management tools like pre-employment screenings, an employee handbook builder, performance management, applicant tracking and employee onboarding tools that can be added on to your plan.

And for businesses with more complex HR needs, Paychex also offers HR packages, HR consulting services, professional employer organization (PEO) services, all-in-one employee onboarding software solutions and hiring services, including AI-assisted recruiting.

Product Integrations

With Paychex Flex, you can also gain access to an ever-expanding library of software integrations, to connect Paychex to popular HR, productivity and financial tools, available through the Paychex Marketplace. Integrations are an add-on service and can be incorporated into any of Paychex’s Flex plans. 

Business Solutions

Paychex’s business solutions set them apart from competitors. With Paychex’s business insurance, you can get complete business coverage for your organization, from a business owner’s policy to workers’ compensation policies, for businesses of all sizes. 

Here are some of the coverage options Paychex offers:

  • Business owner’s policy (BOP)
  • Workers’ compensation insurance 
  • Commercial auto insurance
  • General liability insurance 
  • Professional liability insurance (errors and omissions)
  • Employment practices liability insurance (EPLI)
  • Cyber liability insurance 
  • Commercial property insurance
  • Commercial umbrella insurance

In addition to business insurance, Paychex can also customize business solutions for small, midsize and large businesses. For example, Paychex can help with small business loans, incorporation services, payment processing solutions, funding solutions, tax credits and more.

Plan Options

Paychex offers three tiered plan options, ideal for different business needs. Here’s a look at what each plan includes:

Flex Select

Designed with small businesses in mind, this plan includes:

  • Complete payroll processing from desktop or mobile
  • Taxpay, an automatic tax administration service for payroll tax filing and payment 
  • Flexible employee pay options including paper checks, direct deposit, tip disbursement and pay cards
  • Analytics and reports center with more than 160 standard reports plus custom reports creation 
  • New hire reporting 
  • Up-to-date printed or electronic federal and state labor posters
  • Employee self-service mobile experience
  • Financial wellness and cash flow assistance for employees
  • HR knowledge library 

These basic payroll and HR features should cover the needs of most small businesses. However, it’s good to note that there are many services and features you can add on to this plan to make it work for you. This is a great way to customize your plan to include only the features you need, without having to level up to a more expensive plan option. 

Flex Pro

This plan builds on the tools included in Flex Select, with additional payroll and HR services. Here’s what it includes:

  • All of the features of the Flex Select plan
  • Garnishment payment service 
  • General ledger service to send payroll data to your accounting software 
  • Fast payment options, including same-day ACH
  • Expense management for employee reimbursements
  • Talent management tools, including pre-employment screening and employee handbook builder
  • State unemployment insurance service
  • Workers compensation reporting service 

Just like with the Flex Select plan, you can also add on extra payroll, HR and benefits features to customize this plan.

Flex Enterprise

Larger businesses with more complex needs will find that the Flex Enterprise plan offers a comprehensive payroll and HR solution, helping you stay compliant, train employees and gain insights through custom analytics. Here are the details of what’s included:

  • All of the features in the Flex Pro plan
  • Additional performance management tools 
  • Additional workforce management tools including document management, job costing and labor distribution data
  • Paycheck preview and approval service

Some services, such as benefits administration, workers compensation coverage, time and attendance tools and recruiting and onboarding tools are only available as add-ons. This gives businesses the chance to customize their plan by adding on services as they become necessary, and not paying for services you don’t use in the meantime.

Pricing & Promotions

Paychex is a highly customizable platform, and businesses are able to add on extra services to create the plan that will serve them best. It’s because of this level of customization that Paychex does not make pricing available on their website. Instead, customers are encouraged to fill out a quick form, chat with a representative online or call Paychex directly to get started. 

Like other payroll providers, Paychex also offers special promotions from time to time. For example, at the time this article was written, Paychex was offering six months of free payroll for new business customers.

How Paychex Stacks Up

Now that we’ve covered top features, plans and pricing, let’s take a look at how Paychex compares to other top payroll providers:

Paychex Quickbooks Gusto ADP
24/7 live support across all packages Yes No No Yes
Customize your plan with add-ons —don’t pay for what you don’t need Yes No Yes No
Variety of time-tracking options, including physical time clocks Yes No No Yes
AI-assisted recruiting Yes No No No
HR consulting & PEO services Yes No No Yes
Business insurance coverage options Yes No No Yes
Employee discount programs Yes No No Yes

Bottom Line: Why We Love It

A few key features make Paychex stand out from the competition. First, it’s highly customizable. Paychex may start with three base plans to choose from, but businesses are able to add on features from so many categories like payroll, talent management, workforce management, employee experience, risk management, benefits and integrations, tailoring a plan that’s specific to their needs, without additional features that will go unused if your business isn’t ready for them yet. On that note, Paychex is highly scalable too, able to serve small businesses and startups right alongside large enterprise companies, growing with you as you grow and providing solutions every step of the way. Sure, they’re a payroll provider, but also so much more than that. With business insurance, employee benefits, HR services and more, you can really view Paychex as an unofficial partner who provides customized support to help you reach your business goals. For this reason, we think Paychex is a great fit for business owners who have growth on the docket, although it’s also a great solution for businesses who are simply looking for top-notch payroll software.

Paychex FAQs

Payroll software companies are designed to simplify your payroll workload, save you time and refine error-prone manual processes. But not all payroll companies are the same. That’s why it’s important to find a reputable service like Paychex that can cover all of your business needs from payroll processing and payroll taxes to employee benefits and other HR services, ensuring you stay up to date and compliant with employment regulations and freeing up your valuable time to dedicate to other areas of your business.

As a small business owner, you are responsible for running payroll every period as soon as you bring on a single employee. Beyond processing payroll and deductions, you’re also required to calculate, prepare and file payroll taxes and complete periodic reporting of taxes to the proper authorities. Some employers also need to calculate and pay out tips and commissions, create employee schedules and track and apply paid time off. The more employees you have, the more complicated the process becomes. This is where a payroll software company like Paychex becomes beneficial, saving you time by automating things like time and attendance, and ensuring compliance with payroll taxes and other regulations. 

If you’re looking to switch payroll providers, Paychex makes the process simple. They work with you to collect the necessary paperwork and balance your year-to-date payroll data, and are often able to help pull your data directly from your previous payroll system. In most cases, Paychex can have you up and running in as little as 48 hours after signing up, and their team is available to help you through every step of the transition.

Methodology

The Consumer Rating Difference

Behind Our Best Payroll Ratings

We make choosing the best Payroll easy with expert reviews and rankings.

Here’s the methodology behind our ratings:

icon

Comprehensive Overviews

From preferences, to pricing & more, we cover all you need to know about Payroll Services in our detailed reviews.
icon

Pricing Details

We break down how much the Payroll Services costs, noting everything that’s included for the different price points.
icon

Payroll Services Comparisons

With so many different Payroll Services available, it can be hard to decide which one is right for you. We compare different brands based on your preferences.
icon

FAQs

In case the review wasn't enough to, we also include several FAQs to help ensure you have all you need to make an informed decision.

Trusted & Secure

Trusted & Secure