Elm Sleep Mattress Review

If you’re in the market for a new mattress and want something that priorities both comfort and support, Elm Sleep just might have what you’re looking for.

In this comprehensive review, we’ll take a close look at the Elm Sleep mattress, covering everything from its materials and construction to its unique features and benefits. We’ll also provide a list of pros and cons, and compare it to other popular picks on the market today—so you have all the information you need to decide if it’s your best mattress match.

Last Updated April 2024

brand logo

8.0

8.0

Get $400 Off All Mattresses!

Highlights
Firmness: Luxury Firm, Luxury Plush
Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King
Materials: soft quilting foam, 4lb pressure relieving memory foam, pocketed hybrid coils, and HD poly foam
Design: pocketed hybrid coils provide extra deep support
Trial Period: 180-night home trial
Warranty: Lifetime warranty
Shipping: Free Shipping

What is the Elm Sleep Mattress?

The Elm Sleep mattress is “bed-in-a-box,” hybrid mattress comprised of cushy comfort foam and durable pocketed coils. It’s available in two different models, the Elm Original 13-Inch Hybrid and the Elm Resort Collection 15-Inch Hybrid. The Resort Collection model includes two extra inches of foam.

Both mattresses are available in six sizes, and two different firmness levels: Luxury Plush or Luxury Firm. Regardless of the model, size and firmness you select, you can rest assured that your Elm Sleep mattress was designed to provide premium comfort and superior support.

Pros Cons
Two models to choose from No removal service for old mattresses
Six sizes and two firmness options No financing plans available at this time
Hybrid construction maximizes comfort, support & pressure relief
Temperature-regulating features create a cool sleep experience
Suited for sleepers of every bodyweight and sleep position
Handcrafted by experienced mattress experts in the U.S.
Clean, safe materials and CertiPUR-US® foams
Five trees planted for every mattress sold
180-day trial
Lifetime warranty
Free shipping and returns

Elm Sleep Mattress Details

The Elm Sleep mattresses have been meticulously designed to maximize both comfort and support, making them a great option for every type of sleeper.

Mattress Construction

Both of the Elm Sleep mattresses feature three layers of thick comfort foams that provide deep pressure point relief and support, and a durable coil unit that maximizes air flow and reduces motion transfer. The primary difference between the two mattresses is that the Elm Resort Collection is a 15-inch model that includes two more inches of comfort foam than the Original 13-inch model.

Here’s a more detailed look at what’s inside the Elm Sleep mattresses:

  • Soft quilting foam for cooling encased in a cool and durable stretch knit cover
  • Comfort foam to optimize pressure relief for aching bodies
  • Poly foam to alleviate back pain and lumbar support
  • Pocketed hybrid coils for extra deep support
  • HD poly base foam to provide a sturdy base
  • Durable side panel fabric in a dark color to minimize wear and tear

Mattress Type & Ages Suited For

The Elm Sleep mattress is a hybrid mattress that comes in two different models and two different firmness levels, which means that sleepers of all ages and preferences are likely to find an option that works for them.

Sleeper Types

Elm Sleep provides options for side, back and stomach sleepers alike. The mattresses are available in two firmness levels: Luxury Plush and Luxury Firm. The ultra soft Luxury Plush is conducive to all sleeping positions—especially side sleepers under 280 pounds. The extra support of the Luxury Firm option makes it best for stomach and back sleepers, and side sleepers over 280 pounds who prefer a little more support.

Firmness Level

Both models come in a Luxury Plush and a Luxury Firm option. The Luxury Plush is the brand’s medium firm option, and provides an ultra soft surface coupled with premium pressure relief. The Luxury Firm option is the brand’s firmer option, and provides deeper support while still maintaining the softness most sleepers crave.

How To Get The Elm Sleep Mattress

The Elm Sleep mattress can be purchased directly from the company’s website, https://elmsleep.com/. 

Costs

At the time of this review, the Elm Sleep Original 13-Inch Hybrid mattress ranges from $799 to $1,399, depending upon the size you select. The Elm Sleep Resort Collection 15-inch Hybrid Mattress ranges from $1,099 to $1,699.

Discounts

The brand frequently runs sales on their mattresses, so be sure to check their website for the latest promotions prior to purchasing. Healthcare workers, military, teachers, EMT and police officers can also receive a special discount when they provide a photo of their ID or badge.

Shipping

The Elm Sleep “bed-in-a-box” mattress ships for free via UPS to customers’ homes within four to 10 business days.

Ratings Across Top Performance Areas

Here’s a look at how the Elm Sleep mattress performs in several key areas:

Motion Transfer: Both mattress models feature independent, pocketed coils, which means that when a few of them are compressed by a sleeper changing position, the others remain in position, minimizing the transfer of motion to a second sleeper.

Pressure Relief: The mattresses include a cushy layer of comfort foam that’s specifically designed to provide pressure relief for aching bodies. They also contain a layer of poly foam, which is engineered to alleviate back pain and provide lumbar support.

Temperature Control: The hybrid design of the Elm Sleep mattresses naturally give way to increased airflow and breathability. They also contain a layer of soft quilting foam specially engineered to sleep cool, and a luxurious knit cover that creates a very cool sleeping surface.

Edge Support: Both models include reinforced edges, which prevent the sides from getting saggy, and sleepers from feeling like they might roll off the mattress.

Ease of Movement: Rolling over and shifting positions is a seamless process with both models, thanks to the natural give of the foam. But if you tend to move around a lot while you sleep and don’t want to feel too restricted, you may prefer the Luxury Firm option, which has less of a sinking feeling compared to the Luxury Plush option.

Durability: Featuring premium materials, thoughtful design and reinforcement in the areas that tend to experience the most wear and tear, these mattresses are built to last. Elm Sleep stands behind that with a generous lifetime warranty.

Noise: The noisiest mattresses tend to be those with a coil-only construction—as the coils are worn down, they can begin to squeak when pressure is applied. The hybrid design of the Elm Sleep mattresses means you get all the benefits of coils but none of the noise—the foam offsets the wear and tear on the coils.

Sex: Most sleepers will find Elm Sleep’s hybrid mattresses ideal for sex. They provide an optimal balance of cushion and support, and are very quiet.

Off-Gassing: The Elm Sleep mattresses are made with CertiPUR-US® certified foams, which tend to have minimal off-gassing. The mattresses also include a pocketed coil layer, which optimizes air circulation and allows odor to dissipate much faster than fully foam mattresses.

How Does The Elm Sleep Compare To Other Brands?

Here’s how the Elm Sleep mattress compares to another popular pick from the leading mattress brand Puffy.

Elm Sleep vs. Puffy Lux

There are a lot of similarities between the Elm Sleep mattress and the Puffy Lux. Both are U.S.-made, hybrid models that feature a combination of CertiPUR-US® certified foam and coils to optimize comfort and support. And both come with a lifetime warranty and include free shipping and returns.

That said, there are a few key differences between these two top-selling mattresses:

  • Price: Although both brands frequently run promotions that make a current cost comparison inexact, the Puffy Luxe tends to be the pricier of the two—the base price for a Queen is a few hundred dollars more than the base price of the Elm Resort Collection 15-inch Hybrid, and several hundred more than the Elm Original 13-inch Hybrid.
  • Firmness options: Unlike the Elm Sleep mattress, which is available in two different firmness options, the Puffy Luxe only comes in one—medium-plush.
  • Sleep trial: Elm Sleep offers customers a 180-day risk-free trial; Puffy overs a 101-night trial.
  • Availability: The Elm Sleep mattress is only available online; Puffy Luxe is available for testing and purchasing in some brick and mortar stores.

Company Info

Elm Sleep is a bed-in-a-box brand that launched in 2022. The company sells luxurious-feeling hybrid mattresses that prioritize comfort, support and pressure relief—at an affordable price.

The company’s customer service team can be reached by email at [email protected], and they offer an online chat feature on the company website as well.

Trial Period & Warranty Policy

Elm Sleep stands behind its products with a 180-day trial and a hassle-free lifetime warranty.

Additional Services

In addition to two mattress models, Elm Sleep sells a cooling mattress protector designed to draw heat away from the body, creating a cooler and more comfortable sleep surface.

Our Verdict

The Elm Sleep mattress delivers a high-end feel at an affordable price. Featuring premium materials and meticulous construction, the mattress provides a cool and comfortable sleep experience, and the perfect amount of support and pressure point relief. It’s available in two different models, and each come in six sizes and two firmness levels making it a great choice for sleepers of every weight and sleep style.

FAQ

What is the Elm Sleep mattress?

The Elm Sleep mattress is a hybrid mattress that features both foam and coils. It is designed to maximize comfort, cooling, support and pressure point relief. It is available in two models, each with six sizes and two firmness levels to choose from.

What are the benefits of an Elm Sleep mattress?

The Elm Sleep Mattress is both soft and supportive. Its hybrid design, luxe materials and unique construction make it conducive to every bodyweight and sleep position. Plus, it comes in two models, each with two firmness options to choose from.

How does the Elm Sleep mattress compare to other mattresses on the market?

The Elm Sleep mattress has all the appeal of high-end hybrid mattresses—with a much more appealing price point. Unlike many other top mattresses, Elm’s models are made in the U.S. With two models, six sizes and two firmness levels to choose from, the brand offers more customizability than many other mattress manufacturers.

brand logo

8.0

Get $400 Off All Mattresses!

Methodology

The Consumer Rating Difference

Behind Our Best Mattress Ratings

We make finding the best mattress easy with expert reviews and rankings. Here’s the methodology behind our ratings:

icon

Exhaustive Research

From the optimal firmness for side sleepers to the most effective cooling technology, we dive deep into the data to determine the best option for every kind of sleeper.
icon

Mattress Reviews

No one knows the pros and cons of a mattress like the people sleeping on it. We read thousands of customer reviews to determine which mattresses customers like best.
icon

Personal Experience

Our experts personally test out each top mattress, keeping in mind the features consumers care about most—like materials, design, cooling and firmness.
icon

Side-by-Side Comparisons

From Saatva to DreamCloud, Nectar to Casper, we compare the best mattresses across a number of key criteria to determine how each one ranks.